Skip to main content

Lying in Business Negotiations is Widespread. Is it Effective?


"This… is my final offer..." 
According to a study by the Kellogg School of Management at Northwestern University, "this is my final offer..." is the most commonly uttered phrase in any business negotiation.  90 percent of the time, the statement is completely untrue. 
 To Lie, or Not to Lie, That is the Question
  • Is it ok to lie during business negotiations?  
  • Isn’t negotiating a zero sum game, with winners and losers, with points scored by out-maneuvering your opponent?
  • How about a "white" lie, or exaggeration? Is it ok to stretch the truth?
  • And, since most parties seem to lie to some extent during negotiations, isn’t lying required to keep a level playing field?
This post originally appeared on LinkedIn, June 1, 2015.  Lying in Business Negotiations

In my negotiating experience, which is fairly extensive, I would state no” to all of the above.  Most of my peers, and comprehensive studies, support that position.

  • It’s not ok to lie in business, or elsewhere.  By lying you may, or may not, be able to favorably bias the outcome of some agreements; however the negative consequences will usually outweigh any benefit.  Your credibility may be challenged. Your misrepresentations may be discovered.  Your moral compass will, hopefully, be damaged. And, you may wind up damaging your future ability to negotiate successfully, hurting your career, losing your job, or in prison. 
  • Most negotiations are not a zero-sum game; where one party’s gain comes at another party’s loss (think poker).  Truly winning outcomes are negotiated agreements where both parties succeed, compromise fairly, or, on some occasions, are equally dissatisfied. And, sometimes, the best outcome is no negotiated agreement, at all.
  • If you know it's not true... it's a lie. Period. And, if you are caught lying about one thing, even something "small," it is assumed that you have lied, or will lie, about other things. 
  • Being truthful is not only is morally superior, it usually yields the most successful business outcome; even when the other party is dishonest. I would argue that unless it’s the final deal of your career, and you plan on moving to Bolivia… you’re negotiating in a long-term multi-deal environment where many parties will have knowledge of your deal-making acumen, and honesty.

Is lying during business negotiations illegal?

American law disclaims any general rule of “good faith” in the negotiation of commercial agreements. 
The United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit recently stated:
In a business transaction both sides presumably try to get the best deal. That is the essence of bargaining and the free market. . . . No legal rule bounds the run of business interest. So one cannot characterize self-interest as bad faith. No particular demand in negotiations could be termed dishonest, even if it seemed outrageous to the other party. The proper recourse is to walk away from the bargaining table, not sue for “bad faith” in negotiations.
However, and this is significant, the above statement assumes that no one has committed fraud. As pointed out by the MIT Sloan Business School: The elements of common law fraud are deceptively simple. A statement is fraudulent when
the speaker makes a knowing misrepresentation of a material fact on which the victim reasonably relies and which causes damages.
Damages can result from unfavorable financial terms due to misrepresentation.  Therefore, lying during business negotiations, if fraudelent, may be deemed illegal. 

The Pinocchio Syndrome; why do managers lie?

Even managers who consider themselves highly moral, ethical and honest routinely engage in dishonest statements while negotiating. Professor Francesca Gino, of the Harvard Business School, believes these misrepresentations occur because managers...
“1. Do not realize they are behaving dishonestly; 2. They can't resist the temptation to act unethically; or, 3. Because they find effective ways to overlook or rationalize their choices.”
Professor Gino and her collaborators leverage insights from the growing fields of moral psychology and behavioral ethics to present a 3-principle framework they call REVISE. The framework classifies forces that affect dishonesty into three main categories and then redirects those forces to encourage moral behavior:
  1. The first principle, Reminding emphasizes the effectiveness of subtle cues that increase the salience of morality, and decrease people’s ability to justify dishonesty. 
  2. The second principle, Visibility, aims to restrict anonymity, prompt monitoring and elicit responsible norms. 
  3. And, the third principle, Self-Engagement, increases motivation to maintain a positive self-perception as a moral person and bridge the gap between moral values and actual behavior. 

Final thoughts.

I am not a philosopher, or an ethicist.  I am a businessman and success is my metric of choice.  Lying is not a tactic that yields sustainable success.
Beware of "lies of omission," the intentional failure to tell the truth in a situation requiring disclosure.  This does not mean you must shine a light on every wart... If selling a used car, you must disclose that the air-conditioning doesn't work, but not that you spilled coffee on the back seat (unless asked).
This post focuses on truthfulness in negotiation.  However, lying and misrepresentation are prevalent in other business applications, as well.  From resumes to exit interviews, sales presentations to press releases, lying has become so common in business that it is often considered the norm.  
Most companies have a "code of conduct" requiring truthfulness: Most employees don't read it, they just sign it. We must inspire, create and maintain a culture where lying is unacceptable and unnecessary.  Lead by example.
Lying, whether on online dating sites, resumes or during business negotiations, is inauthentic; and, whether remembered as "fraudulent" or simply a "white lie" it diminishes our perception of self-worth, it eats away at our sense of our own character.
Primarily a character with good intentions, Pinocchio's lies resulted in his turning into a donkey, being forced to join a circus, and then swallowed by a whale - a fairly high cost to learn his honesty lesson.  Hopefully your tuition will be less expensive.
(c) David J. Katz, June, 2015 - San Francisco
As always, your opinions and feedback are welcomed... DJK

Popular posts from this blog

Beware of Wombats & Other Vampires

You are surrounded by dangerous WOMBATS. They’re everywhere. Sometimes they hide in plain sight, easy to spot. Other times they are well camouflaged, requiring heightened awareness to identify them. You need to stay alert, it’s important to avoid them. WOMBATs resemble ordinary, productive tasks. However, they are vampires for time and resources, weapons of mass distraction.WOMBATs are seductive. Working on a WOMBAT feels productive.WOMBATs are bad for your career.WOMBATs are bad for your business.WOMBATs infiltrate your work day (and your personal time). Strike them down.WOMBATs may be be ingrained in your company culture: “We’ve always done it that way…” WOMBAT Metamorphosis Alert: A task or project that wasproductive in the pastcanevolve into a WOMBAT in today's environment.Your comfort zone is populated with WOMBATs.More on comfort zones, here.Some people are WOMBATs in disguise. Stay away from them, they are vampire WOMBATs.If you don’t control your WOMBATs, your WOMBATs will…

Taking Tips From a Younger Generation

Phyllis Korkki, an assignment editor at The New York Times, visited the garment district in Manhattan to interview designers as part of a story for the newspaper’s Snapchat account. Credit George Etheredge/The New York Times
What Could I Possibly Learn From A Mentor Half My Age? Plenty.

How on earth did I become an “older worker?”

It was only a few years ago, it seems, that I set out to climb the ladder in my chosen field. That field happens to be journalism, but it shares many attributes with countless other workplaces. For instance, back when I was one of the youngest people in the room, I was helped by experienced elders who taught me the ropes.

Now, shockingly, I’m one of the elders. And I’ve watched my industry undergo significant change. That’s why I recently went searching for a young mentor — yes, a younger colleague to mentor me.

How Randa and the Fashion Industry are Adapting to DIY

The term 'Do It Yourself' has turned into a phenomenon over the past decade and is continuing to gain momentum, especially in the fashion industry. From interactive design stations at Topshop, to custom shoes at Jimmy Choo, every level of the fashion industry is dipping their toes into the pools of DIY.

"Many industry insiders think it is just the beginning. Ask about the future of fashion, and the answer that is likely to come back (along with the importance of Instagram and the transformation of shows into entertainment) is personalization," says Vanessa Friedman from the New York Times.